Thomas jefferson and sally hemings ohio university. Founding father thomas jefferson has had a significant impact on america, american government, and american culture. The announcement in 1998 that dna testing proved some link between the. The most compelling element of all, however, is her extensive and careful research, which often allows the evidence to speak for itself.
It is true that sallys sons madison and eston were freed. The hemings case against jefferson rests, essentially, on three skeletal pieces of evidence, framed by a selective exclusion of all the exculpatory evidence pointing to jeffersons innocence. Madison hemmings, the third of sallys four children who lived into adulthood, published a memoir filled with important information about his mother, his father, life at monticello and. Harriet hemings may 1801 1870 was born into slavery at monticello, the home of thomas jefferson, third president of the united states, in the first year of his presidency. Dna tests on male descendants in thomas jeffersons family and that of sally hemings offer genetic evidence that jefferson fathered slaves. Dna tests on the descendants of thomas jeffersons family and of jeffersons young slave, sally hemings, offer compelling evidence that the. Buy a cheap copy of sally hemings book by barbara chaseriboud. An excellent lesson to scholars on how to apply meticulous academic rigor to an accretion of the evidence. History, memory, and civic culture jeffersonian america taylor, jan ellen, onuf, peter s. Fuelled by recent dna evidence of the hemings jefferson relationship, the miniseries sidesteps much of jeffersons. Has dna testing proved that thomasjefferson fathered at least.
Somewhat metatextual commentary, this is a history of how american culture has reacted to the idea that jefferson had a lengthy relationship with hemings and fathered her children. Madison hemings grew up on jeffersons monticello plantation. But jacksons team ran into a roadblock when none of the living white male madisons would publicly submit to a dna test. Nearly five years after dna testing provided compelling some argue overwhelming evidence that jefferson fathered at least one child with a young slave named sally hemings, about 150 of. In spite of the paucity of evidence, those who believe in this long affair between jefferson and hemings argue that sufficient proof could be found in the memoirs of madison hemings. Thomas jefferson spent years raping his slave sally hemings.
Dna test finds evidence of jefferson child by slave the. In 1852, when harriet beecher stowe finished uncle toms cabin, she wrote to a congressman, horace mann, who happened to be nathaniel hawthornes brotherinlaw, to beg a favor. Jeffersonian democracy, books, articles, and internet commentaries continue. An american controversy is the definitive look at a centuriesold question that should fascinate general readers and historians alike. He is the author of twelve books including the forthcoming hell to pay. He may not have been informed of toms whereabouts or he may have kept thomas woodsons request for secrecy when he learned of it later in life.
Madison, however, was born in 1805, after tom had left monticello possibly in 1803. Most historians believe her father was jefferson, who is now believed to have fathered, with his slave sally hemings, four children who survived to adulthood. Born into slavery by his mothers status, he was freed by the will of his master thomas jefferson in 1826. Hemings and jefferson had a longstanding romantic relationship, and had at least one and. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father of all hemings s children. The jefferson enigma jefferson post dna jeffersons blood. In november of 1998, following the release of dna tests which, combined with the historical record, strongly point to thomas jefferson as the father of at least one of sally hemingss children, the thomas jefferson memorial foundation formed a research committee to verify the findings, gather all relevant evidence. Nov 29, 2004 forensic dna evidence interpretation is the most comprehensive resource for dna casework available today. Other evidence supports thomas jeffersons paternity as well, including his presence at. Background dna study thomas jefferson sally hemings.
Daniel jordan, monticello president, and others that the dna of william hemings be tested adainst the jefferson dna and also against eston hemings dna. In 1999, dna tests proved compatible with the possibility that jefferson had fathered eston hemings, sallys youngest son. Madison hemings was born in 1805, the third of the four children of sally hemings who reached adulthood. Discusses jeffersons health, the dna study, the jefferson hemings scholars commission report, paris, madison hemings and jeffersons overseer. Annette gordonreed makes madison hemings her chief witness and his credibility her central contention in her interrogation of jeffersons defenders. The society of madison descendants referred jackson and kearse to a. There are many people who feel this dna study, either alone or combined with other historical evidence, resolves the issue once and for all. And the evidence available, now that it has been examined fairly and in detail by annette gordonreed, makes clear that she was very likely the loved mistress of thomas jefferson. Thomas jefferson spent years raping his slave sally. New book disputes claim jefferson fathered children of slave hemings. Those who denied the possibility that thomas jefferson was the father of any of sallys children hoped that dna evidence would settle the question. Westerinens brother john is a descendant of jefferson and hemings. Annette gordonreed, a professor of law at new york law school, doesnt take a position for or against the proposition that thomas jefferson may have had a liaison. This web version of the final report of the research committee on thomas jefferson and sally hemings is organized into six sections, evaluating the dna science and the documentary evidence.
In the majority view, the dna evidence is consistent with jefferson being the father of eston hemings, plus the historical evidence favors jeffersons paternity for all of hemings children. David works had originally resisted the new dna evidence, but after he read the commissioned reports, he became convinced of jeffersons paternity. Eston hemings jefferson was born to sally hemings, a mixedrace slave, on may 21, 1808 in monticello, virginia. He was the third of her four childrenfathered by her master, president thomas jeffersonto survive to adulthood. Provides a history of the politically motivated allegation and presents evidence for an alternate paternity candidate. Yet, notwithstanding this extensive influence, a cloud hangs over jeffersons reputationhis alleged affair with sally. The recent publication of the results of dna tests implies that eston hemings, sallys.
An american family, by annette gordonreed, and in defense of thomas jefferson. Descendants of thomas woodson greeted news of the dna tests with dismay. This is true, however, after deep research i found a deceased son of madison and suggested to dr. Sally hemings, born in 1773 in virginia, worked on the monticello plantation of thomas jefferson. Over the years, however, belief in a thomas jeffersonsally hemings relationship was perpetuated in private. Dna testing of members of the jefferson and hemings families in. James madison hemings january 18, 1805 november 28, 1877 was the son of the. Andrew holowchak is the author of many books about thomas. Mar 03, 2001 but in 1998, new dna evidence that traces y chromosomes passed from father to son strongly indicated that mrs. Foster conducted dna tests on 5 male line descendants of 2 sons of.
This miniseries details the complex reallife relationship between thomas jefferson sam neill, author of the declaration of independence and his slave sally hemings carmen ejogo. The dna testing found no genetic link between the hemings and carr descendants. Madison hemings provided an account of his mothers life that was published in. The jefferson enigma jefferson post dna jeffersons. Dna evidence in 1998 supported the widely accepted conclusion that he was the son of thomas jefferson, the third president of the united states and the principal author of the declaration of independence. The dna evidence is reasonably compelling on its own, establishing a perfect. The jefferson miscegenation legend in british travel books. Annette gordonreed and the jefferson dna myth history news. I would like to address the issue of the thomas jefferson dna study and give my first hand account regarding the misleading headline in the science journal nature dated november 5, 1998. Her 1997 book thomas jefferson and sally hemings, an american. Dna tests are incompatible with the possibility that eston hemings was fathered by peter or samuel carr, jeffersons nephews, the sons of dabney carr and jeffersons sister martha and the most plausible alternatives to jefferson himself as a father. Two of her childrenmadison and estonindicated that jefferson was their father, and.
In january 2000 the thomas jefferson memorial foundation accepted the conclusion, supported by dna evidence, that jefferson and hemings had at least one and probably six offspring between 1790 and 1808, though this conclusion was quickly and ardently contested by other individuals and groups. Dna tests show that a descendant of eston hemings carries a jefferson gene. Recently the madison hemings branch decided not to press forward with dna testing. Madison hemings, who learned carpentry at monticello, told the pike. Buy a cheap copy of thomas jefferson and sally hemings. Additionally, the dna study found no link between the descendants of field jefferson and thomas woodson 17901879, whose family members have long held that he was the first son of thomas jefferson and sally hemings. New book disputes claim jefferson fathered children of.
Instead, the evidence has resulted in renewed controversy and has demonstrated that even in cases where the scientific evidence is clear, its interpretation remains ambiguous. Written by leaders in the fields of biology and statistics, the book emphasizes the interpretation of test results and provides the necessary formulae in an easily accessible manner. Born into slavery by his mothers status, he was freed by the will of jefferson in 1826. Fawn brodies book on the subject received a good deal of criticism from. Thomas jefferson sally hemings the truth about a founding. Madison hemings grew up on jeffersons monticello estate. The dna testing found no genetic link between the hemings and carr descendants, refuting jeffersons grandchildrens assertion that his carr nephews fathered sally hemings s children. Monticello affirms thomas jefferson fathered children with sally. Madison hemings the treaty legend thomas jefferson heritage. The monticello foundation commissioned its study, which in 2001 concluded jefferson was likely the father of eston hemings and the other children. Jun 06, 2009 annette gordonreed and the jefferson dna myth.
New book disputes claim jefferson fathered children of slave. Dec 22, 2018 in response to fosters dna evidence, in january 2000, the thomas jefferson memorial foundation stated its belief that jefferson and hemings had in fact been sexual partners, and that jefferson was the father of hemings six children including beverly, harriet, madison and eston born between 1790 and 1808. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father. Ever since a 1998 dna test was performed on sallys youngest child, eston, scholars have thought for years that a jefferson male. Sally hemings and thomas jefferson napa valley college. His words have helped shape policies on everything from the relationship between church and state to the scope and limits of the federal government. Annette gordonreed and the jefferson dna myth history. The theory was that if you could find a male line descendant of thomas jefferson whose dna y chromosome matched the dna y chromosome of a male line descendant of eston hemings and thomas woodson, then that would indicate that thomas jeffersons dna y chromosome had been passed down through a relationship with sally hemings. Dna evidence has proved that jefferson and hemings had six children together while jefferson kept. Nov 30, 1977 sally hemings by barbara chaseriboud was an insightful novel depicting the life and times of sarah sally hemings as a slave, concubine and enslaved mistress to our third potus, thomas jefferson. Shortly after it appeared, dna testing established a genetic link between a male jefferson and eston hemings, madisons brother. Long before the dna evidence was revealed, fawn brodie showed that. If jefferson had an affair with sally hemings, we have to.
Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father of all hemings children. Excluding the recent dna evidence, there are some incongruities in the woodson story. Sally hemings 17731835 was an enslaved woman owned by founding father thomas jefferson 17431826. This study resulted in a great deal of controversy on the issue of thomas jeffersons paternity of the children of his slave sally hemings. Dna test finds evidence of jefferson child by slave the new. Since this was written in 1997, dna testing has confirmed that sally hemings was not the mistress of any of the men in the carr family. Her son madison hemings could not be included in the study because his line of male.
Two of her childrenmadison and estonindicated that jefferson was their father, and this belief has been perpetuated in the oral histories of generations of their descendants as an important family truth. A founding father and his family ties the new york times. Then, in 1998, dna tests were done on the descendants of madison hemings and the descendants of his brother eston. When this stirring work by philadelphiaborn parisbased sculptress and historicalfiction writer barbara chaseriboud first appeared in 1979, it was dismissed by. The dna study did prove paternity of a jefferson family member and. The notes further state that descendants of madison hemings were not tested. Largely as a result of revived interest in this case following gordonreeds book, a ydna analysis of carr, jefferson and hemings. The jefferson hemings dna study as told by herbert barger, jefferson family historian. She was a nursemaid to his daughter mary and traveled with the family to paris. Aug 30, 2011 new book disputes claim jefferson fathered children of slave hemings. Shay banksyoung, a descendant of madison hemings, had grown up with a family tradition of descent from jefferson. Julia jefferson westerinen is descended from eston hemings. Nov 01, 1998 dna tests on the descendants of thomas jeffersons family and of jeffersons young slave, sally hemings, offer compelling evidence that the nations third president fathered at least one of her. James madison hemings was the son of the mixedrace slave sally hemings.
352 1452 1348 184 716 498 206 114 913 1052 1216 663 1162 912 284 608 92 925 474 1131 1081 876 354 526 616 208 1370 151 311 101 268 114 162 831 679 1180 535 1403 290 1153 553 528 220 1480 745 1479